Carl Deirmengian, MD, FAAOS, receives Kappa Delta Elizabeth Winston Lanier Award for the first FDA-Authorized diagnostic test for use in orthopaedics
ROSEMONT, Ill. (February 5, 2020)—Carl Deirmengian, MD, FAAOS, received the Kappa Delta Elizabeth Winston Lanier Award. His body of work includes 15 years of synovial fluid research, eventually leading to the Alpha-defensin Lateral Flow Test, the first Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-cleared diagnostic test in the field of orthopaedic surgery, as an adjunct aid in the evaluation and detection of Periprosthetic Joint Infection (PJI). The Kappa Delta Awards recognize research in musculoskeletal disease or injury with great potential to advance patient care.
According to the AAOS, PJI occurs around an implant such as an artificial knee or hip joint. Because joint replacements are made of metal and plastic, it’s difficult for the immune system to attack bacteria that make it to these implants, causing a possible infection. Infections must be diagnosed properly, as the treatment of an infected versus an uninfected joint replacement is dramatically different. It’s estimated that by this year, there will be approximately 65,000 hip and knee replacement infections, costing the U.S. health care system $1.6 billion.[i]
“There’s a level of ambiguity and uncertainty that can occur when surgeons interpret the traditional laboratory tests used to diagnose PJI, because the laboratory reporting of these tests does not coincide with official diagnostic recommendations for PJI,” said primary investigator, Dr. Deirmengian, orthopaedic surgeon and associate professor of orthopaedic surgery, Rothman Orthopaedic Institute in Philadelphia.
For a medical condition without an approved test, medical organizations such as the Musculoskeletal Infection Society (MSIS), often create a criteria-based scoring system to make a diagnosis, which uses a combination of already existing hospital tests that are not intended to diagnose joint infection. They then establish cutoffs (the value that distinguishes between positive and negative results) which a surgeon has to know in order to properly interpret these tests and diagnose the patient.
“Essentially, these tests weren’t specifically made for the orthopaedic community and you can imagine the complexity that a surgeon faces having to know all of the MSIS cutoffs and their applications,” said Dr. Deirmengian. “Additionally, these cutoffs need to be properly interpreted since they vary through the literature, which can lead to an inconsistent application of the diagnosis.”
Knowing the risks and potential complications of PJI, Dr. Deirmengian’s interest in molecular biology and chemistry sparked an idea early in his medical career.
When Dr. Deirmengian started his residency at the University of Pennsylvania, genomics––which is the study of all of a person’s genes––wasn’t widely utilized in orthopaedics. However, once he saw synovial fluid (fluid around certain joints to lubricate and reduce friction during movement) for the first time, he realized it was the perfect tissue to study at a genomic level due to its simple cellular composition.
In 2005, Dr. Deirmengian published his first report[ii] (partially funded by an Orthopaedic Research and Education Foundation grant) which identified potential synovial fluid biomarkers for PJI. He was able to determine that neutrophils (a type of white blood cell) in an infected knee had a different gene responses than neutrophils in a knee that wasn’t infected. These findings introduced the idea of using these biomarkers to diagnose PJI. In recognition of this work, he received the Mark B. Coventry, MD Award from The Knee Society.
“Now that I knew which genes turn on when there is an infection, I wanted to develop a simpler and less expensive test to detect changes in the synovial fluid at the protein level based on what I learned in the genetic study,” said Dr. Deirmengian.
He studied 23 different proteins and demonstrated that different families of synovial fluid protein biomarkers can be used to potentially diagnose PJI.[iii] By knowing the specific protein families that were elevated in the synovial fluid of infected patients, Dr. Deirmengian and his team conducted a four-year study at the Lankenau Institute for Medical Research in Wynnewood, Pa. to determine which proteins would be best at diagnosing PJI.
“Out of those tested, alpha-defensin was identified as what we thought was the best protein in the synovial fluid to measure infection,” said Dr. Deirmengian. “This was the first time that the alpha-defensins were proposed as a synovial fluid test for PJI.[iv]”
Dr. Deirmengian and his team started a fully functioning diagnostic orthopaedics lab to offer the alpha-defensin and other tests to orthopaedic surgeons around the country. It quickly became one of the largest laboratories in the world, receiving hundreds of synovial fluid samples a week, allowing them to conduct more extensive research.
As other institutional studies confirmed the work of Dr. Deirmengian and his team, the next step was to take the alpha-defensin test through the FDA review process. This included a prospective, multi-center, adjudicator-blinded clinical trial to evaluate the clinical performance of the alpha-defensin Lateral Flow Test for PJI, including sensitivity and specificity. The Lateral Flow Test is a disposable cartridge-like device that hospital laboratories can utilize to get an alpha-defensin result in 10 minutes.
The patient cohort in their study included 305 adults with a total hip or knee arthroplasty, exhibiting signs and symptoms that demonstrated a likely need for a revision arthroplasty. Of the group, 131 were men and 174 were women with a mean age of 64.8 years.
Among the results of the study Dr. Deirmengian and his team found:
- The test yielded approximately 94.3% sensitivity and 94.5% specificity in diagnosing PJI.
- This study verified previous findings including:
- The antibiotic treatment of patients did not appear to affect alpha-defensin’s diagnostic performance, despite the significant effect of antibiotics on the performance of other traditional tests in the literature.[v]
- There was no significant difference of the diagnostic performance of the Alpha-defensin test on patients with systemic inflammatory disease (e.g., rheumatoid arthritis) or in the setting of culture-negative versus culture-positive PJI.
In May 2019, the FDA authorized the Alpha-defensin Lateral Flow Test for PJI. According to the FDA, prior to this authorization, there were no FDA-authorized diagnostic tests specifically designed to help health care professionals determine whether the inflammation around a prosthetic joint was due to an infection or another cause.
“This test is intended to be used in conjunction with other diagnostic methods, but it is unique in that it is intended for orthopaedics, which means that the laboratory-reported result can be directly used by the surgeon, without the complexities of applying other cutoffs and alternative interpretations,” said Dr. Deirmengian. “There’s value in having a test that’s intended to diagnose these infections, so every surgeon, regardless of subspecialty, training, or knowledge, can be equally effective in using the test and understanding its result.”
About the Kappa Delta Awards
In 1947, at its golden anniversary, the Kappa Delta Sorority established the Kappa Delta Research Fellowship in Orthopaedics, the first award ever created to honor achievements in the field of orthopaedic research. The first annual award, a single stipend of $1,000, was made available to the Academy in 1949 and presented at the AAOS meeting in 1950. The Kappa Delta Awards have been presented by the Academy to persons who have performed research in orthopaedic surgery that is of high significance and impact.
The sorority has since added two more awards and increased the award amounts to $20,000 each. Two awards are named for the sorority national past presidents who were instrumental in the creation of the awards: Elizabeth Winston Lanier, and Ann Doner Vaughn. The third is known as the Young Investigator Award. For more information about the manuscript submission process, please visit aaos.org/kappadelta.
Kappa Delta Foundation
Kappa Delta Sorority is a national organization for women with nearly 260,000 members, more than 500 chartered alumnae chapters and 169 active collegiate chapters. Established in 1981, the Kappa Delta Foundation is a 501(c)3 organization whose mission is to secure funds for the educational, leadership and charitable purposes of Kappa Delta Sorority. The foundation is supported by member donations and bequests that fund programs and initiatives such as scholarships, internships, grants and more. Kappa Delta National Headquarters is in Memphis, Tennessee. For more information, visit www.kappadelta.org/foundation.
About the AAOS
With more than 39,000 members, the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons is the world’s largest medical association of musculoskeletal specialists. The AAOS is the trusted leader in advancing musculoskeletal health. It provides the highest quality, most comprehensive education to help orthopaedic surgeons and allied health professionals at every career level best treat patients in their daily practices. The AAOS is the source for information on bone and joint conditions, treatments and related musculoskeletal health care issues and it leads the health care discussion on advancing quality.
For more information, contact:
|Lauren P. Rileyfirstname.lastname@example.org|
- The initial funding of this body of work was provided through a resident research grant in 2003 from Zimmer (Warsaw, Ind.) and from an OREF Resident Research Grant in 2004.
- The prospective study, diagnostic devices and contract research organization described in this manuscript were paid for by Zimmer Biomet (Warsaw, Ind.)
Conflicts of Interest
Principal Investigator – Carl Deirmengian, MD
- Consultant for Zimmer Biomet, Biostar Ventures, Trice Inc, and previously Synthes.
- Currently serving as consultant and chief medical officer of CD Diagnostics, a subsidiary of Zimmer Biomet.
Co-author – Keith Kardos, PhD
- Chief Scientist at CD Diagnostics before its exit to Zimmer Biomet
- Later an employee for Zimmer Biomet in his role in CD Diagnostics
- Currently not a Zimmer Biomet Employee
[i] Kurtz SM, Lau E, Watson H, Schmier JK, Parvizi J. Economic burden of periprosthetic joint infection in the United States. The Journal of arthroplasty 2012;27:61-5 e1.
[ii] Deirmengian C, Lonner JH, Booth RE, Jr. 2005. The Mark Coventry Award: white blood cell gene expression: a new approach toward the study and diagnosis of infection. Clin Orthop Relat Res 440:38-44.
[iii] Deirmengian C, Hallab N, Tarabishy A, et al. 2010. Synovial fluid biomarkers for periprosthetic infection. Clin Orthop Relat Res 468:2017-2023.
[iv] Deirmengian C, Kardos K, Kilmartin P, et al. 2014. Diagnosing periprosthetic joint infection: has the era of the biomarker arrived? Clin Orthop Relat Res 472:3254-3262.
[v] Shahi A, Parvizi J, Kazarian GS, et al. 2016. The Alpha-defensin Test for Periprosthetic Joint Infections Is Not Affected by Prior Antibiotic Administration. Clin Orthop Relat Res 474:1610- 1615.